The Sims 4 Thoughts

The Sims 4 Review: What’s different from The Sims 3?

SIMS4_Logo_Final_rgb

Yes, it’s tactile! Yes, it’s emotional! Yes it’s weird & smart at the same time! But why is The Sims 4 different from The Sims 3 and why should you (or not) purchase it?

reviewnote

We’re about 2 weeks away from the release of this game and a lot of people are on the fence should they get or not get the game. We’re not here to list you all the features, objects and interactions in the game since we couldn’t explore them all at The Sims 4 EU Preview Event and even if we did, it would be better to leave it for September. This review is here to help you out on getting off that fence of indecision.

Please note that all views mentioned on this post are our own!

First thing you’ll notice in the game are probably more loading screens! If you plan to move your Sim around the World much, there are plenty of them that you’ll encounter: Loading Screens for Neighborhoods, Lots inside those Neighborhoods (excluding Public Spaces) and Worlds.

At first, this idea might sound awful for The Sims 4, but is it really? On the PC we played The Sims 4 (couldn’t see the specs, all I know is that it’s a Win8 computer), it took 3, 5 and sometimes 10 seconds to load the destination my Sims were headed to. After loading screen disappeared, you could play the lot you selected instantly without any lags or stutters to get your Computer used to it.

Now, let’s go back and see how Loading Screens functioned in The Sims 3

I tested The Sims 3 yesterday with nothing but the Base Game and all updates installed. The main loading screen took 20 seconds and it took me 1 minute to load Sunset Valley.

Were the results same after I installed all the Expansion and Stuff Packs? Absolutely not! It took me 30 seconds just to load the Main Menu and 3-4 minutes to load Sunset Valley.

TS3W 2014-08-18 21-07-51-08

I won’t be using the results for the all EPs and SPs installed since it won’t be fair to compare it to The Sims 4 Base Game.

It also takes some time to load Textures and different Create a Style settings on the Lot after it’s zoomed in. Until they’re all loaded, they sometimes appear as white objects. This is only for a short moment and the time of them loading depends on the Computer’s specs. Huge compliments to The Sims 3 Team for adding so many customization options to the game, but it would take a super computer to make all of that work smoothly and without crashes.

I want to go back to The Sims 4 Loading Screens once again before we close this chapter. Imagine if there were 2 people eating at 2 different buffet tables: one who could eat everything from the table (The Sims 3), and the other one who ate just the things he liked (The Sims 4). Who will get a stomach ache (or in this case, Crash). The answer is, The Sims 3! Why is that so?

When loading a World in The Sims 3, the game loads absolutely everything (Objects, Sims, Lots, Saves) that are included on that World. After playing for some time, you might have a chance for your game to freeze on various situations: Create a Style, switching from Live Mode to Buy Mode and similar or even sending your Sim to another lot. On that freeze, the game puts a lot of pressure on your Computer since it loaded a lot of stuff that’s included in the World you’re currently playing in, which mostly, will make your Game Crash or even make your Computer collapse (watch out for those Blue Screens of Death  😯 ).

The Sims 4 functions very simple in that case: you load a Lot and a Public Lot that’s included in your Neighborhood that you like and it probably won’t put a lot of pressure on your Computer – which will lead to much less Crashes. What’s also cool about loading The Sims 4 is that there are no more loading screens for the Main Menu! You just open the game, skip the intros and voilà – you’re in the Main Menu!

Capture

For me, that’s a huge plus, but let’s see what’s this game is actually made of…

Create A Sim in The Sims 4 is really different from previous Sims Games. Not only that there are new techniques that you can use to create your Sim, but the interface of it is much more simple to use.

There aren’t really any steps that you must follow in order to create your Sim, although things like First Name, Last Name, 1 Trait out of 3 and a Lifetime Aspiration is mandatory.

TS4CAS 2014-07-08 22-23-54-53

The push, pull & twist feature that you can use on your Sim’s face and body is really cool and a lot of manipulation options can be seen from different perspectives. For example: you can adjust your Sim’s posture rotating your Sim so the back can be visible. It really does allow you to create all types of Sims: Beautiful, Charming, Weird, Scary and so on.

TS4CAS 2014-07-08 21-29-57-94

With Create A Sim in The Sims 3, there were lots of manipulation options as well. Still, all those sliders were a bit confusing and you could only edit your Sim’s face (you can also edit your Sim’s body, but there were only 2 sliders, making all the Sims somehow identical in their body looks).

TS3W 2014-08-18 22-21-19-89

Here’s the sad part about The Sims 4 CAS (and somehow the whole game) – it lacks so many color and texture customization options! Hair color, Clothing, Shoes, Accessories, Tattoos – all limited to the presets The Sims Team provided in the game. I always loved how in The Sims 3 I can change the different aspects and areas of my Sim’s clothing.

TS3W 2014-08-18 22-24-16-86 TS3W 2014-08-18 22-25-28-64

The Sims 4’s CAS is not making this ”battle” with The Sims 3 easy with it’s customization options. It’s limited and some clothing don’t even have that much presets. Hopefully they’ll add some presets to the existing clothes we have with Game Updates that they will release (I checked the game’s menu – it has ”Game Updates” feature that redirects to EA Help website).

TS4CAS 2014-08-18 22-44-14-50

Once again, The Sims 4 still wins with the performance compared to The Sims 3. All clothing that there is (there’s much more clothing, hair and other CAS Accessories in The Sims 4 than in The Sims 3 – probably to make up for the loss of CASt) and all hairstyles load right up when you click on them. With The Sims 3 Base Game, you would have to wait 3-4 seconds for everything to load, and for some reason when you click on a hairstyle/clothing, it takes 2 seconds for it to apply on your Sim.

When it comes to Create A Sim, I think both of them have something it’s opponent doesn’t have; The Sims 3 has a wide variety of customization options, while The Sims 4 features much more fun and detail into sculpting your Sim.

Sims need a place to stay, right?

The Sims 4 offers 2 Worlds: Willow Creek (left) and Oasis Springs (right).

Thanks SimFans.de for providing these

249 245

The Map View in The Sims 4 you just saw above couldn’t be more simple (probably because the Worlds are simple as well…maybe too simple…)

Map View in The Sims 3 is 3D and offers a flyover over each area that’s available to visit by Sims.

TS3W 2014-08-18 23-21-14-80

Personally, I’m okay with the 2D Map in The Sims 4, but I still love the Map View in The Sims 3 which offers an overview of the whole World.

When moving in, you can choose a Household to merge with, move in an empty lot or move in a furnished/unfurnished house. It’s the same process in The Sims 3 as well, so there aren’t any differences (except User Interface changes).

The Sims 4’s Build Mode is a mixture of The Sims 3’s Buy Mode, Build Mode and brand new in The Sims 4: Room Catalogue. The Room Catalogue lets you place Pre-Built Rooms instantly.

The whole Build Mode is simply pushing, pulling, putting together different rooms and more. Of course, there is a traditional way where you can start down with just 1 wall and then connect multiple walks, making it a room. You can even take a whole building you created, rotate it and place it wherever you want.

The Sims 4_ Build Mode Official Gameplay Trailer(1) 114 The Sims 4_ Build Mode Official Gameplay Trailer(1) 151 The Sims 4_ Build Mode Official Gameplay Trailer(1) 170 The Sims 4_ Build Mode Official Gameplay Trailer(1) 362

In The Sims 3, there are a lot of ways you can build your House or a Community Lot, but that would take for hours. The reason for that is, in case you want to change something onto a Lot you already build (such as center the house), you would have to destroy the whole thing and start again. This is why building in The Sims 4 is much more easy and fun.

TS3W 2014-08-18 22-59-08-22 TS3W 2014-08-18 23-17-03-16

Furnishing a home is yet another meh moment for The Sims 4. The lack of Create A Style Tool doesn’t allow you to change the fabrics, for example, your sofa and change it’s colors however you want. It really wouldn’t be a big deal if they just provided more presets for objects.

Photo by Simply Ruthless

Capture

The producers still found a way how to fill that gap though; the team confirmed that they made over 1000 Objects just for Buy Mode itself. Never before were there so many objects in The Sims Base Game

The outcome of some houses in The Sims 4 is still really amazing. The roofs have much more options now and you can also place Rounded Foundations and Fences. All of this can be done by just pushing and pulling!

TS4_054_PE_HOUSE_01_001 TS4_054_PE_HOUSE_02_001 TS4_054_PE_HOUSE_03_002

It’s still unknown will they ever add one of the most missed features from The Sims 1, The Sims 2 and The Sims 3..

Screenshot-2603

The most important Mode of any The Sims game is definitely Live Mode, and it looks like that’s been The Sims 4’s Team main focus. While playing the game, you’ll notice that Sims are now much more responsive and aware of their environment. Not only that you can Satisfy their Needs and Whims, but now you also have a job to control, and if you want, satisfy their Emotional needs. Sims can have over 15 Emotions, and it’s always fun seeing how they react to Sims with totally different Emotional state than theirs. Happy Sims have a power to cheer up Sad Sims, Angry Sims can ruin someone’s day, Uncomfortable Sims usually have low need bars such as Hungry, Bladder; Bored Sims have their Fun Need bar low and they’ll probably be on the lookout for something exciting.

Another great feature is multitasking! Your Sim can do so much more with it and their Needs and Skills can benefit at the same time thanks to it.

18 3

The Sims 3? Yeah, your Sims may use buffs or moodlets as a replation to Emotions in The Sims 4, but still there will be some inappropriate times when, for example, your Sim gets in a fight and gets a negative moodlet for it. They’ll throw in some Angry Animations here and there, but no Sims or objects will be affected by their buff. The buffs are just there to tell you if your Sim was injured, hurt, sad, hungry and such, otherwise you wouldn’t know a thing.

Here is an example: I made my female Sim’s husband get divorced from her. She did cry out some tears randomly why standing, but you can’t see that while she’s doing an action on an object or interacting with another Sim. They don’t have feelings about what they experienced and went through, they only have moodlets that will fade away really quickly and it will be like her husband didn’t even ask for a divorce. Any action she made afterwards was just rainbow and happiness.

Screenshot-2606

I really love how The Sims 4 Sims are aware of what’s going on in their Environment. I had my Sim play the Computer and suddenly his roomates popped in and had a chat on the bed. He didn’t just ignore them, he started chatting with them as well all while playing his Video Game on the Computer.

10

I tried to make a similar scenario in The Sims 3 but it didn’t work out quite well. I made his Mom and Sister gossip but he didn’t even try and look at them. That whole time he was just waiting there for his command – even though the Free Will was turned on.

Screenshot-2607

When you look at this way, it’s nothing much, he just refused to join the conversation, but when you look at The Sims 3 as a whole, you’ll notice that they’ll never make smart decisions and everything they do is just full of robotic movements and soulless expressions. They don’t care what’s happening around them, all Sims want in The Sims 3 is… success!

That’s right. What I noticed is that most of Expansion Pack we got for The Sims 3 aim for one thing and that’s make your Sim rich and top their Careers. After all, the idea of it just gets boring and there’s no much thing to do after you become one of the best paid Sims in the Town. There’s no point of that when basically no one will admire you and see how proud and confident you are after getting a promotion.

The Sims 4 does have that aspect of succeeding in your Sim’s life, but it’s not the main aspect.

The primary goal of The Sims 4 is just making your Sim Happy (or Sad if you want to) without doing so by making money. If your Sim likes money that is possible, but still not the main goal. This game is about socializing with other Sims, seeing how they react to your success or failure, encourage them, make them lose confidence about themselves and so much more! Each Emotion under certain conditions will unlock certain interactions, and it may be hard to get those interactions back since every moment in The Sims 4 is unique and Sims will know that! They remember all the things you did in the past (especially if they’re significant) and do not forget easily. Each Sim day, you’ll encounter at least 1 Sim moment which will trigger your emotions a little bit as well. I found so many funny moments in the game, only this time, everything they did was on purpose, unlike in The Sims 3 where we just laughed at glitches Sims caused.

2 7 9

If you look at The Sims 3, it indeed has some creative features and options that The Sims 4 will never have, but after you create that Sim with unique pattern and color, build them a house with all the unique textures, you’ll have to push the play button once. That’s when you realize that everything you customized on them and the house you built for them, they just won’t care, and that’s when everything you did for them seems unappreciated .

Thanks for reading this Review and I hope you make a choice you find the best!

Let us know in the comment section below what do you think about this Review and make sure you check out our The Sims 4 Preview with more Screens and more info!

About the author

Jovan Jovic

Founder of the Sims Community website. I do plenty of things around here including writing articles such as "Top 10 Disney Princesses in The Sims", social media management, video content creation, streaming and more!

35 Comments

Click here to post a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • I completely agree on the last part: Sims in The sims 3 seem to not care about other at all. Really makes the game less enjoyable 🙁
    At least I’m looking forward to TS4! Bring on the Emotions 😀 😀

  • I believe that my Sims 2 had more emotion then the sims 3. My sim pee herself in public and she cried even when folks are trying to cheer her up or comfort her. She would stop talk to the other sim and when he quit talking she was crying again.
    Sims 3 do cry but, they do act like nothing is wrong between the tears almost to a aggravation…. …

  • I’d like to compliment you on what is by far the best article on The Sims 4 I’ve seen yet. You gave the game the credit it deserves while still acknowledging its shortcomings in a very constructive way. Thankyou for showing that there is still room for rational thinking and constructive criticism in the gaming community.

  • Your review totally nailed the last part. That’s the problem about The Sims 3. Don’t get me wrong, I love it just as much as the next sim fan and I have ALL expansion packs. But sims in sims 3 feels too robotic and empty to me now. I don’t understand Why are so many people against Emotions. I think It’s the most interesting feature ever in the sims franchise.

  • I think that the sims 4 map is much better than sims 3 solution.

    Sims 3 solution had big problems:
    – displacement: to go to far places took a lot of time! and it is an issue when the game is a simulation that doesn’t go on real time.
    – lots. after some time, when I began to have some expansions, I had to fight to be able to have any kind of lot. It was a big effort, adding solars, etcetera. It was not fun, cause the city loss sense and charisma.

    Sims 4 solves these two problems
    – displacements: I don’t need to displace. It happens. I will not lose my precious sims life with it!
    – New expansions means new areas that I will only need to charge! awesome!

    So, I’m happy about these two game decissions.

  • I applaud the writer for this article…honest comparison to the sims 3 and 4. I am very excited for the game but I realize this is a new game with new stuff never before in a sims’ base game. Probably the feature that bummed me out the most that won’t make a return to S4 is the CASt. But then again, I will be making a sacrifice for what seems to be, smooth gameplay and less choppy, lag or freeze that I’m currently experiencing in the S3.

    I loved the S3 when it came out and until a few weeks ago, played the game every single day. Now I will be moving on to a new game that will hopefully be just as satisfying as S3 was for 5 years. 😀

  • “Undecision” is not a word. Look it up. It’s not there. I’m still reading your article, so I cannot comment yet, when I was derailed by this unnecessary addition to the English language. Try “indecision”. 🙂 :-)) 😀 :laugh: :-(( ?:-)

  • Sounds like a very interesting game, which is what I was hoping it would be. I still think I’ll be surprised when I start playing it. Thanks for the review! Nice job and check that dictionary – it’s your friend whenever you write. 😉

  • Thank you for this rational and unbiased review. I was definitely on the fence for the last year about getting this game. . I am heading to Origin now to pre – order the digital deluxe limited edition.

    • I didn’t say The Sims 3 is ”crappy”. I just think Sims in The Sims 4 have much more feelings and are much more realistic when you look at how they behave.
      Both games have unique content and gameplay that the other game doesn’t have.

      • Jovan wrote: “I didn’t say The Sims 3 is ”crappy”. I just think Sims in The Sims 4 have much more feelings and are much more realistic when you look at how they behave. Both games have unique content and gameplay that the other game doesn’t have.”

        hmm…interesting. I didn’t say which game I found to be “crappy” and which game I found to be “crappier.”

        But I think you just did.

        • I didn’t also say which one is which. I didn’t take the comparative of that word in consideration and only used that word in positive.
          As I stated in the post, this is my view of the game and what I think about The Sims 4 in comparison with The Sims 3.

  • In sims 2, once a teenager was betrayed by her boyfriend, and by thinking about that, she cried for more than one (sim) day. It was fun!

  • I really like the loading screen idea! Now I don’t have to waste ~ 10 minutes of my day not trying to stare at my computer screen! 😎

  • After the announcement of The Sims 4 I barely even touched The Sims 3. It just seemed boring. It was always boring, but now I actually really realized it. Whenever I tried to make myself play the game, I turned my game on, created a Sim, moved him to a new house and made him get a job. But when I have to turn my game off and go somewhere (for example do my homework or take the dog for a walk) I never save my game, because… well… it’s boring! I don’t feel like continuing with this Sim. The game lagged, especially in Isla Paradiso where it freezes ever minute for 10 seconds or more (which is irritating), the main loading screen takes way too long for me to load and I just get bored and start to do crunches (AND I HATE EXERCISE). My computer isn’t crappy, it runs games like Watch Dogs, Far Cry 3, Tomb Raider (at least these are the good graphic games that I’ve played recently without any lag). And The Sims 3…. well let’s just say you need to have Bull Gates’ money to acquire the perfect computer that suits this game. It still makes me sad about the things they’ve cut from The Sims 4 (like it’s officially confirmed that there won’t be any supernatural stuff… ever… like… what??), but they said that they will add the toddlers and the pools in an EP, so I’m not really worried about those. It’s nice they’ve added 2 neighborhoods in the base game and they added other unique stuff in just the base game that I can’t think of right now. I’ve been VERY skeptical about The Sims 4 in the begging, I actually wrote some pretty bad comments for it in the past. But now after I played the demo, I really want it and I’ll probably get used to the missing things (we all do at certain times) Just to say that you shouldn’t judge a book by it’s cover and if you don’t want to waste your money on that “crappy game” just watch Let’s Plays of other YouTubers and see for yourself if you want this game. Don’t make bad or good reviews before the game is even released.

    • I have to agree with your point about graphic issues with TS3. Last year I upgraded my computer myself and had extremely good specs, and an outstanding graphics card! My PC handled everything I threw at it with ease and them some, until I played TS3. When I moved my sim to a cafe and then back home, the rendering of the textures still lagged, showing those awful white blocks! Even if I just played sims in their home it would lag slightly. This and the issues of constant glitches in the game was so tiresome, I was hardly playing it anymore. I do like the designs of TS3 but this is at the cost of gameplay. Essentially, all I ever had time to do was create a family with beautiful features and clothing, create a home and then move them in and this in itself took such a long time. Once in the game all I ever seemed to do was click on a Sim to make them do something and it just became boring. I will miss the textures and colour wheel of TS3, but right now I’m enjoying TS4.

      I’ve now played TS4 for 2 days and so far I’m liking it. I don’t miss the toddlers at all, I never liked them in TS3 they were, to me, just a waste of time. An illustration of how “robotic” the Sims in TS3 are, is they don’t automatically care for their babies and children, they have to be told to hug the baby/child. This is not the case in TS4 the sims do this by themselves and it is really refreshing to see! In essence, I can now sit and watch the family interact with little input from me. The “needs” do decay faster, but then rather than having to rush to click on the fridge, or the Sim as we had to in TS3 we can now just click on the needs bar and the sim will go and eat! Simple! I also greatly like the improved build mode, this is much less time consuming than TS3 and there is some really nifty pieces to build with, and the roof tool, well I just like this soo much. It is soo much easier than TS3 it’s almost like child’s play! I do find the camera movement a bit wayward even in TS3 mode, but hopefully I will get the hang of this.

      I really like the fact that when I’m creating a family in TS4 I can save it as I go along without having to leave the CAS screen, I don’t know if this was possible in TS3. The hair is much better than before, no choppy ends and there is a fair amount of styles and more colours for hair. The push n pull features of creating a sim are good, and there is plenty of clothes to choose from for the time being. The same thing applies to building a home. In fact TS4 also has more frequent save time running in the background so the whole creation aspect, is soo much more pleasant than TS3 whereby you would have to save frequently the build before the game crashed, and then it seemed (to me) it would crash anyway because there’s been so many saves during the build. TS4 has nailed this on the head!

      So in essence, TS4 is a base game with lots of TS3 features missing, but this in turn makes TS4 more user friendly to a wider audience without the need to have some kind of technical knowledge of how to play the game or the constant expense of having to upgrade a computer’s graphic card. The custom content in TS4 is in .package format so only a zip extractor is required and the package is then put into the Mods folder, just this aspect of it makes TS4 a winner for all concerned. The items and clothing in TS4 are really good as well as being quite modern.

      All in all, I like TS4, I like the fact that I’m not so involved with my family I can let them get on whilst I have fun watching them. This was how it used be in Sims 2 and I like this legacy in TS4. The load time of the game is negligible, and the loading screens in the game, are nothing compared to the issues of game Isla Paridiso in TS3, which I never played again in TS3. I also like the simplified graphics, the content and sims look really cool. I’m really pleased I took the plunge and bought it. There is already great CC being developed and this will greatly enhance my gaming experience with TS4.

      So if you’re in any doubt, think of the advantages of sitting back and watching your family grow and interact amongst themselves and others rather than constantly being a controller. This is a game for all ages, and won’t require a constant learning curve on what is making the game function and, as it stands at present, shouldn’t require constant expensive computer upgrades. I think TS4 has put the fun back into simming. :-))

  • Wow, I never knew that you had such a way with words! I completely agree with you on everything you said. But I would also like to hear on what you have to say on no toddlers, because that’s a MAJOR change from all the games.

  • I really like that pyramid house in Oasis Springs. Another thing that should have been included was how easy it was to navigate in the sims 4 cas and how it wasn’t laggy like the sims 3 was.

  • I am kinda disappointed with TS4. Yes, the range of emotions are awesome. The graphics are spectacular! But the gameplay? It’s like we got thrown back in time to TS2. The world is so small and constricted! In the 2 world we only have the option of visiting bars, lounges, museums, parks and if you want to make it, a nightclub. What happened to the restaurants (seriously, sims can’t survive on only chips!), the theater, the stadium, etc! No cars, no toddlers, NO POOLS! *faints* The neighborhoods being so active is great, but what use is that activity if they only have so many places to visit! The only real fun you can have is at home and that is just sad! Parties? Forget about having fun, its more a chore and FAR too short lived. Going to work is the worst! The sim just disappears from the curb, you have no idea where they work and you can’t even make friends there. Besides the graphics and the interactions between sims and their intelligence, I feel TS4 has taken a step back with this game. I hope these features (and more) get released with DLC, (of course, they want to make money!) because as of now I am disappointed with TS4 (not to mentioned bored). Back to the vast (albeit emotionless) world of TS3 I go.

  • I realy like the Sims 4, it looks better than 3 in many ways, but maybe the only thing that I preffer from the 3 than 4, is the sims detail, I mean, the sims graphics (I dont care much about the enviroment graphics) from the Sims 3 seems to be more realistic than in Sims 4. Yes, thats the unique thing that I would like to be more like sims 3. For the rest, Sims 4 is better, specialy I love the multitasking and the smart-emotion that seems to be included in this game.

  • I think this review is not good, you are loving Sims 4 personally, sims 4 needs some work for a real Sims 4. It’s not worth its price.

  • […] With the newest update of Sims 4 the focus on character development rises. You can adjust Sims identities to represent actual family members are give them personality types related to their actual personalities as well. These Sims are more emotion based, and your goal is to make them “happy”. Happy Sims also have the power to cheer up sad Sims, and their everyday interactions mimic the actions of people in real life. […]